12/4/06..
2006 Full Season Grade: C-
The Giants finished the season on a serious down note. Their final record tied them for last place in the division, so the Alou's skipped town and left it up to new manager Bruce Bochy to pick up the pieces.
Barry Bonds never really got things going as old man time works his spells on even the best of athletes. Jason Schmidt also had a down season and has decided to follow the Alou's over the Golden Gate Bridge and far away. Left in their wake is a ton of work and not much prospects to help out so what does management do? They sign more old players.. hey, whatever works, right?
Look for the Giants to be heavy players in the free agent market in order to fill in while they rebuild the farm system. With that in mind, don't expect many division titles or playoff participations for a few years.
5/10/06.. RoxHead.. Report Card
The Giants are currently going through a tough stretch. Every publication, web site and sportswriter is dogging them for being too old and slow. It is possible that they are correct this time but it is too early to count them out of it.
The Giants starting rotation is still solid once Matt Morris with his three-year, $27 million contract gets it going. Their pen is suffering but should get better once Benitez gets some arm strength. There might be a problem if they need to trade for players in July and August because they have repeatedly compromised their farm system while trying to win with Bonds by trading prospects for veterans and forfeiting draft picks by signing free agents.
Look for them to tread water until they get some players healthy. If they can hang within 5-10 games of the front runners by the Allstar break, then they should be just fine. Also, the media circus should lighten up once Bonds gets past the Ruthian holy border line.
2/1/06... Rox Head.com
The 2006 Giants will have the best starting rotation in the division with the addition of Matt Morris and a full year of Matt Cain, but their bullpen took a hit losing Scott Eyre. These moves won't matter as much as the reappearance of the big bopper, Barry Bonds. The simple fact is if Bonds plays, then the Giants will win the division and if he doesn't then they will struggle to win as many as they lose.
There, that's all you really need to know.
Actually, the Giants didn't do a lot of maneuvering this winter because they didn't have to. Bonds makes such an incredible difference in the batting order that the whole make up of the team changes from average to dangerous with just his presence. Alou is still one of the better managers in baseball and the Giants sell a lot of tickets which allows the management to spend some extra money in July if needed.
Prediction:
If Bonds is healthy, then look for the Giants to finish first in the West with a record of 90-72. If he isn't... 81-81.
-------------------------------------------
2005 Full Season Grade: D+
The Giants were all about Barry Bonds. They didn't have him for the majority of the year and they struggled because of it. Once he decided that his body was ready to play the last few weeks of the season, then the team responded by making a little run at the Padres before fading late. The depressing thing if you are a Giants fan was the fact that they had relatively few injuries except closer Armando Benitez and, of course, the big one to Bonds and yet they still finished under .500 for the season.
The front office did try to make something of the year by playing 16 rookies, with starter Matt Cain leading the way, so you can't say that it was a total waste of a season like the DBacks and the Dodgers had. Felip Alou is going to manage another year at least, so there is still strength in the coaching department.
Mid Season Grade: F
This team stinks. They are old and they stink. They have very few good things to talk about. I was completely wrong with the prediction below.
A long, long summer is in store, though Bonds could be back -- the latest guess -- by mid-August. His chase of Babe Ruth may give San Francisco fans something to cheer about. But that will be about it.
Preseason Prediction:
With Bonds and his injury, the thinking for how the Giants do this year has to be reconsidered. They still have a very good veteran team and will win the division even with Bonds playing only half the season, but it will be a bit of a struggle to hold off the Padres. Let's reduce their wins a couple and predict a 90 win season at the most.
Sources: MLB.com, ESPN.com
SI.com, TSN.com,
Prosportsdaily.com
TOP TEN PROSPECTS
(John Sickels)
1. Tim Lincecum, RHP
2. Jonathan Sanchez, LHP
3. Marcus Sanders, 2B
4. Billy Sadler, RHP
5. Kevin Frandsen, 2B
6. Eddy Martinez-Esteve, OF
7. Emmanuel Burriss, SS
8. Fred Lewis, OF
9. Nate Schierholtz, OF
10. Travis Ishikawa, 1B
TOP TEN PROSPECTS
(J.P. Schwartz)
#1. Tim Lincecum, P
#2. Nate Schierholtz, OF
#3. Jonathan Sanchez, P
#4. Kevin Frandsen, 2B
#5. Dan Ortmeier, OF
#6. Emmanuel Burriss, SS
#7. Benj Copeland, OF
#8. Fred Lewis, OF
#9. John Bowker, OF
#10.E. Martinez-Esteve, OF