11/20/06..Report Card
2006 Full Season Grade: C-
The DBacks regressed in 2006. They were so bad that they even decided to change uniform colors for the 2007 season. The franchise is only nine years old and already they are attempting to change their identity.
Actually, they weren't as bad as all that. In fact, they recovered nicely after the Jason Grimsley affair in early June and even stayed in the hunt for a postseason spot as late as mid-August. When it became apparent that a post season birth was out of the question, they worked more of their younger players into the lineup and the results were promising. First baseman Conor Jackson (.291 average, 79 RBI) established himself as a solid everyday player, and fellow rookies Stephen Drew (.316) and Carlos Quentin (nine homers in 166 at-bats) showed why the team considers them integral parts of its future and gave fans a good taste of what will be in store for 2007 and beyond.
The biggest surprise was Eric Byrnes in centerfield. He led the team in home runs and stolen bases and his all-out playing style and love for the game also had the fans cheering for him. It'll be interesting to see if they re-sign him for the 2007 season because of Chris Young who was tagged as the CF of the future.
The rotation needs lots of work behind Cy Young award winner, Branden Webb, as does the bullpen. The D-backs don't figure to make a long-term investment in an expensive free agent, even though their pitching staff has issues to address. Parting with Russ Ortiz during the season while still owing him $22 million might be enough to persuade them to seek other avenues to bolster their staff. Also, the loss of fan favorite Luis Gonzalez to free agency will hurt in the middle of the lineup.
But the main reason behind Arizona's reluctance to enter into the free agency frenzy is because of the over baring deferred contract mess created by the previous owner, Jerry Colangelo. They lost $353 million from their inaugural season of 1998 through the 2004 campaign, according to audited financial reports. In addition, he said the club was responsible for $254 million in deferred payments to 18 players, 15 of whom were no longer with the organization and are paying $25 million to $30 million a year towards those contracts.
6/28/06.. Rox Head
The Diamondbacks are not a good team. They have no rotation and spotty offense. How they went on that nice run in May was beyond me but since even before the Jason Grimsley affair, the team began to show its true colors. I predicted below that they would win around 73 games for the season and that mark appears to still be accurate by going 3-17 in their last 20 games.
The DBacks should not be in the hunt for trades to improve their team by trading prospects. They have one of the best farm systems in baseball, so why bother. They have every opportunity to get better and quickly if they keep those young players in the fold.
2/1/06... Rox Head.com opening statement
The Diamondbacks biggest concern remains their pitching. They dealt disappointing starter Javier Vazquez, a top of the rotation type pitcher, to the White Sox for Orlando Hernandez, who is a 4th or 5th starter at best, and lost Shawn Estes in free agency. They did pickup Miguel Batista but then traded two bullpen pitchers for catcher Johnny Estrada. The trade of third baseman Troy Glaus and commitment to first baseman Conor Jackson means that the team will be losing a ton of homers.
Basically, the DBacks are in a rebuilding mode. They will not only have trouble scoring runs but they will also have difficulty getting outs. The middle of the lineup still has some bite with Shawn Green, Chad Tracy, Luis Gonzalez and newcomer Jackson, but the rest of the group is weak at best.
Prediction:
Look for the D'Backs to fall to last in the west behind the Rockies with a record of 73-89.
---------------------------------------
2005 Full Season Grade: C+
Arizona improved a lot record wise from 2004 to 2005 by winning 26 more games. They also finished the year very well going 41-32 in the last 70 games or so. However, they did it by signing veteran players that have a limited shelf life. Signing Craig Counsell and Shawn Estes was fine but the big money free agents, Troy Glaus and Russ Ortiz, was not smart economically. This pattern of spending money they don't have in order to buy playoff spots is commendable but isn't a way to build a long-term successful franchise. Oh sure, they will have some good years here and there, but those seasons will always be followed by crummy ones such as the 2004 team.
The DBacks are in the process of hiring a new GM, so it will be interesting to see if this one will change the old philosophy and start building from with in and staying out of the free agent market (only one player of the starting eight is home grown) or continue on trying to plug holes with the current crop of hot, yet over priced free agent.
Mid Season Grade: C-
Some good things happen for the Phoneys in the first half of the season. In the power department, they have six hitters who have at least 10 homers apiece with the team as a whole is third in the league in homers (with 102). Brandon Webb, Brad Halsey and Javier Vazquez have had decent first halfs. The team is also playing extremely wellon the road with a 21-22 record. However, their team ERA of 4.81 is fourth worst in the NL and have only 2 complete games. Also, they have lost two of their starting rotation to the DL in Russ Ortiz and Shawn Estes and they are playing under .500 ball at home.
The division is so weak that if they could get things together and possibly make a good trade or two in the next month or so, then they can still make a run at San Diego but can you really take seriously a team that has been outscored in the first half by 85 runs??
Preseason prediction:
It's hard to tell how the Diamondbacks will do this year because of all the changes. This years team is so completely different that even diehard Phony phans will need a program for quick player reference. Most think that losing Randy Johnson will hurt their staff, but they lost 111 games with him so it's doubtful they could do worse this year. In fact, the D-backs will make a turnaround similar to the 1999 team that qualified for the playoffs. The difference being that this year they won't be playing in October because probably won't even win half their games.
Sources: MLB.com, ESPN.com
SI.com, TSN.com,
Prosportsdaily.com
TOP TEN PROSPECTS
(John Sickels)
1. Justin Upton, OF
2. Chris Young, OF,
3. Carlos Gonzalez, OF
4. Miguel Montero, C
5. Alberto Callaspo, 2B
6. Micah Owings, RHP
7. Brett Anderson, LHP
8. Gerardo Parra, OF
9. Dustin Nippert, RHP
10. Brooks Brown, RHP
TOP TEN PROSPECTS
(J.P. Schwartz)
#1. Justin Upton, OF
#2. Carlos Gonzalez, OF
#3. Chris B. Young, OF
#4. Micah Owings, P
#5. Miguel Montero, C
#6. Alberto Callaspo, 2B
#7. Emilio Bonifacio, 2B
#8. Alberto Gonzalez, SS
#9. Cyle Hankerd, 1B
#10. Gregory Smith, P
TOP TEN PROSPECTS
(BaseballProspectus)
1. Chris Young, CF
2. Justin Upton, CF
3. Carlos Gonzalez, RF
4. Miguel Montero, C
5. Alberto Callaspo, INF
6. Dustin Nippert, RHP
7. Mark Reynolds, UTL
8. Brett Anderson, LHP
9. Micah Owings, RHP
10. Emilio Bonifacio, 2B